Menu of Metrics

This chapter presents a suggested menu of metrics, emerging from the data and discussions presented above. It is perhaps the most directly actionable output of this study, aimed primarily at supporting Dóchas members to move to more locally led models of development. The menu is not exhaustive, but is intended as a starting point from which members, local partners, and donors can deepen discussions – a tool to build upon in order to strengthen measurement and accountability in the shift towards LLD. It incorporates and builds on some of the metrics currently used by some members, moving further beyond traditional programme-level indicators by incorporating dimensions of power, autonomy, and system-level change – a perceived gap identified in the research. These dimensions provide a more comprehensive basis for assessing progress towards LLD, ensuring that both operational effectiveness and structural change are captured.

It is not an exhaustive table, and any indicators/means of verification employed will need to be SMART and workable.

A Menu of Metrics

This menu uses nine dimensions emerging in the discussions. Dóchas encourages members to use this as a reference point for reviewing and strengthening existing MEAL frameworks, partnership assessments, and donor reporting. Indicators are not intended to be prescriptive, and may be adapted to local contexts and used selectively based on factors such as geography, objectives, or organisation type.

Table 3: A menu of metrics

Domain What to measure How to measure
Decision-making, influence and equitable partnerships
  • Extent of local partner involvement in strategic decisions and programme design
  • Local partner influence over priority setting and resource allocation
  • Degree of shared decision-making between INGO and local partner
  • Degree of local partner participation/influence on sector-level coordination and policy platforms
  • Evidence INGOs ensure/promote visibility of local partners
  • Percentage of programmes where local partners influence concept development and design
  • Percentage of programmes led by local partners across project cycle
  • Evidence of changes in programme priorities based on local partner input
  • Proportion of key decisions made jointly between INGO and partner (e.g. ≥80%)
  • Documentation of joint planning processes and co-created priorities
  • Number and level of decision-making fora, where INGO is active, held for local partner
  • Number of local partner engagements in national/regional forums
  • Evidence of local partner contributions to policy or coordination outcomes
  • Number of times local partner put forward by INGO for public, stakeholder or media engagement
  • Number of times local partner credited for programme impact
Financing and resource allocation
  • Proportion of funding directly managed and controlled by local partner
  • Degree of flexibility in use of funds and reasonable budget adjustment during implementation
  • Predictability and duration of funding for local partner
  • Equality of overhead funding between INGO and local partner
  • Transparency of overall budgets between INGO and local partner
  • Accessibility of funding to local partner, e.g. simplified, language-sensitive funding applications
  • Access to direct financing and funding for local partner
  • Percentage of INGO funding passed to local partners
  • Annual increases in grant to partner ratios
  • Percentage of total active project budgets controlled by local partners
  • Percentage of funding provided as multi-year commitments
  • Percentage of indirect/overhead costs allocated to local partners
  • Average duration of partner funding agreements
  • Number of budget reallocations approved annually
  • Percentage of programmes where local partner has visibility of total budget
  • Number of funding applications accepted in local languages
  • Number of context-appropriate funding application templates
Risk Sharing
  • Distribution of financial, operational, reputational, and security risk
  • Percentage of partner contracts with risk-sharing clauses including, e.g., adaptive clauses, sharing of currency fluctuations, sharing of costs on insurance mechanisms
  • Percentage of projects requiring co-funding or pre-financing by local partners
  • Average number of days of pre-financing required by partners
  • Number of partnerships with co-designed risk management frameworks
Capacity strengthening and organisational development
  • Evidence that organisational development is core objective of partnership
  • Strength of governance, MEAL, and operational systems
  • Strength of financial management systems
  • Development of locally owned systems and policies
  • Evidence of local partner ability to manage programmes independently
  • Evidence of INGO facilitating local partner access to direct financing
  • Evidence organisational development is leading to greater autonomy
  • Degree of progression in organisational maturity of local partners
  • Results from organisational capacity assessments
  • Number of partnership contracts including organisational development
  • Number of contracts with provision for flexible organisational development budget lines
  • Percentage of local partner policies developed internally
  • Evidence of reduced reliance on INGO support
  • Percentage of local partner financing coming from direct grants or other forms of funding
  • Audit results, quality of financial reporting; compliance scores
  • Movement of local partners across defined capacity or maturity levels over time
Compliance and reporting
  • Evidence of improved accessibility in compliance and reporting for local partners
  • Scaled requirements based on funding amounts
  • Presence of harmonised tools for partnership assessments and due diligence
  • Evidence of clear and graduated compliance requirements for partners
  • Number of due diligence passporting agreements joined
Sustainability
  • Evidence of continuity of programmes after funding ends
  • Level of integration into local systems
  • Percentage of initiatives continuing post-project
  • Percentage of projects including ex-post evaluation plans
  • Evidence of handover or institutionalisation within local structures
MEAL and adaptation
  • Use of locally produced data for programme adaptation
  • Inclusion of locally relevant indicators in MEAL systems
  • Balance between accountability and learning
  • Functionality of feedback loops
  • Percentage of indicators co-designed with local partners
  • Number of documented programme changes based on monitoring data
  • Evidence of internal reflection processes vs reporting outputs
  • Number of decisions influenced by community feedback
Transparency and accountability
  • Evidence of two-way accountability mechanisms
  • Responsiveness to community feedback
  • Presence of systems for both upward and downward accountability
  • Reported stakeholder perceptions of trust, transparency, and collaboration
  • Evidence of shared responsibilities and mutual accountability
  • Percentage of feedback addressed or acted upon
Community ownership and accountability
  • Level of community leadership in initiatives
  • Community perception of success and relevance
  • Evidence of community involvement in monitoring and evaluation
  • Percentage of programmes with community members engaged in programme planning, activities, and MEAL
  • Number and functionality of community-led structures

This framework should be read alongside the findings in previous sections, which provide the evidence base from which these metrics were derived.

Share this page: