What our member organisations are measuring
Across both the interviews conducted with participating member organisations and the documentation reviewed, we found strong and growing commitment to the shift towards LLD across the Dóchas membership. There is evidence that participating member organisations increasingly frame LLD not simply as a programming modality, but as a broader shift in relationships, decision-making, accountability, and power within the development and humanitarian sector.
Organisational documents emphasised respectful partnerships, community leadership, participation, mutual accountability, and the strengthening of local systems. LLD is commonly associated, among these members, with decentralised decision-making, community ownership, and the repositioning of INGOs as facilitators and convenors rather than primary drivers of development processes.
However, member organisations are at very different stages in the move towards LLD. Some demonstrate relatively advanced efforts to formalise LLD commitments through dedicated strategies, partnership frameworks, governance arrangements, and accountability mechanisms. Others articulate LLD more broadly through organisational values and partnership principles. This variation reflects the evolving nature of LLD across the sector and the absence of standardised approaches for conceptualising and operationalising LLD commitments. It also reflects the different histories and programming modalities of member organisations.
It is important to note that how much, and what, is measured in relation to the move to more locally led models of development varies significantly across participating members. While a small number have set LLD-related benchmarks against which they report to donors, there is no consistent approach to measuring the shift to LLD. The research also reflects more of what a small number of organisations are trying to track rather than how they are tracking (the indicators).
Domains and types of indicators currently used by some member organisations
These domains represent what some members are tracking or aspiring to measure; it is not intended as a best practice recommendation but rather reflects some of the challenges and opportunities for the sector in developing MEAL for LLD. For further details, please refer to Table 1 (page 11) on the PDF report. Or rollover the tiles below:
Decision making power and influence
Example Indicators
-Percentage of proposals co- created with partners and project stakeholders
Number of CSOs that engage effectively with relevant stakeholders
Percentage of national staff in leadership positions
Presence of local governance documentation and structures
Representation of women, youth, persons with disabilities, and marginalised groups in governance and decision-making structure
Equitable partnerships
Example Indicators
Percentage of partners positively reporting their relationship
Financing and resource allocation
Example Indicators
Presence of commitments to multi-year and flexible funding arrangements between INGO and partner in policies and procedures
Percentage of programme budget on-granted to local partners
Capacity strengthening and organisation development
Example Indicators
Percentage of partners with capacity development plans
Percentage of partners supported (through financial means, human resources, etc.) to become more sustainable beyond the project cycle
Sustainability and systems strengthening
Example Indicators
Continuation of services beyond project support
Number of local structures strengthened
Transparency and accountability
Example Indicators
Presence of local partners and stakeholders in learning events
Community ownership and accountability
Example Indicators
Presence of participatory tools in MEAL systems
Local partners – tracking LLD and their role in MEAL
When asked during focus group discussions (FGDs) and workshops whether they measure and evaluate changes relating to LLD, local partners said they did not. They spoke more broadly about their roles in MEAL processes and how they are not generally positioned as independent designers of measurement systems, but rather as key generators of programme-level evidence within externally defined frameworks.
The perception is that what they measure is shaped less by their own institutional priorities and more by the operational, compliance, and reporting requirements of INGOs and donors. The in-country workshops provided an important opportunity to deepen reflection on the measurement of the shift towards LLD.
Through facilitated discussions and engagement with examples of LLD indicators used elsewhere, participants were able to explore the relational, institutional, and transformational dimensions of LLD more explicitly, including issues of power, decision-making, ownership, trust, participation, and accountability.
In practice, current measurement by local partners largely focuses on the following:
Delivery and outputs
Local partners predominantly measure what they implement. Indicators focus on activities delivered, outputs achieved, reach and coverage of interventions, and immediate changes at the community level. While recognising that tracking outputs at this level is necessary, this reflects a model where measurement is closely tied to accountability for delivery, reinforcing the positioning of local partners as implementers rather than decision-makers.
Capacity strengthening – referenced but weakly measured
Feedback suggested that while capacity strengthening and organisational development for local partners is happening, its measurement remains ad hoc, externally defined, and focused on activities such as training delivered rather than outcomes or impact. There is limited systematic tracking of institutional growth, financial and operational autonomy, or organisational resilience over time.
Community participation and inclusion – not decision-making or influence
Local partners can generate robust data on community participation and how programmes are reaching different groups – tracking participation, engagement of women, youth, and marginalised groups, and the functionality of community-level structures. However, while community participation is systematically measured, influence is not. Local partners capture who is involved, but not who holds decision-making power or control over resources. Inclusion is operationalised primarily as participation rather than leadership or authority.
Feedback systems – process over accountability
Local partners play an active role in collecting community feedback, complaints and response data, and perceptions of service relevance. However, these feedback systems primarily support programme improvement and upward reporting rather than assessing whether accountability relationships are equitable or reciprocal. Accountability is treated as a process – feedback collected and documented – rather than as an outcome relating to strengthened relationships or improved responsiveness.