Dóchas LLD Report

Executive Summary

Background and purpose

Dóchas commissioned a qualitative study to explore how the local partners of our member organisations define, experience, and measure success in locally led development (LLD). The study was conducted in Ethiopia, Kenya, and Uganda and engaged 28 local civil society organisations (CSOs), community-based organisations (CBOs), cooperatives, and women-led organisations partnering with 8 Dóchas member organisations.

The primary aim was to generate evidence on what local partners themselves consider to be meaningful indicators of progress towards LLD, and to use those perspectives to inform discussion on more inclusive and contextually grounded monitoring, evaluation, accountability, and learning (MEAL) frameworks across the Dóchas membership. This study forms part of Dóchas members’ broader commitment to advancing equitable partnerships and supporting the transition towards locally led development cooperation.

Dóchas commissioned the Vashi Impact Group (VIG) to undertake this research. The findings presented in this report reflect the perspectives and beliefs of participating local partners. They are not intended as a definitive or statistically representative assessment of progress across all Dóchas member partnerships.

The main purpose of the study is to enable and support members and other stakeholders to further strengthen efforts in moving to locally led models of development.

Key Findings

Findings reflect the perceptions and lived experiences of local partners. These perspectives are presented as important evidence in their own right – whether or not they fully align with the experience of member organisations or other sector stakeholders. Understanding how partners see the partnership, and more general approaches to development, is in itself a critical step towards more equitable collaboration.

Measurement of progress towards LLD

Dóchas member organisations demonstrate strong and growing commitment to LLD, increasingly framing it as a broader shift in power, decision-making, ownership, and accountability rather than simply a programming modality. Measurement approaches are strengthening, with a number of member organisations tracking various elements and levels of participation, partnership quality, organisational strengthening, accountability, and community engagement. How much, and what, is measured in relation to the move to more locally led models of development varies significantly across participating members. Measurement systems remain stronger in capturing programme performance and partnership processes than in assessing deeper transformational shifts related to power redistribution, local autonomy, and decision-making authority.

From the perspective of local partners, measurement practices overall remain heavily shaped by donor and member organisation reporting requirements. Local partners are primarily positioned as generators of programme-level evidence within externally defined MEAL systems, rather than as independent designers of measurement frameworks based on local context and systems.

Power imbalances remain a defining feature of the development system as perceived by local partners. Authority over strategic direction, programme design, and funding allocation is largely concentrated among donors and international non-governmental organisations (INGOs). Local partners consistently distinguish between consultation and participation, and genuine leadership – they are often engaged after key decisions have already been made. Gradual shifts are evident in some long-term partnerships and consortium models, but these remain uneven and context-specific, and differ across locations and partner types.

While partners highlight areas where some progress has been made, financing structures are largely perceived as a central constraint on LLD. Local partners reference indirect funding flows, short-term project funding, delayed disbursements, rigid donor conditions, unrealistic and limiting co-funding requirements, and limited flexibility in budget utilisation and repurposing in the case of changing contexts. Financial, operational, and other risks are seen as disproportionately carried by local organisations, particularly smaller and grassroots partners.

Local partners consistently emphasise the importance of being involved from the earliest stages of strategic direction, priority setting, and programme conceptualisation. While improvements in consultation and co-creation are acknowledged, priorities, strategies, and funding frameworks are still frequently developed externally by donors and INGOs before local partners are engaged. Positive examples highlighted during discussions, where co-creation has been meaningfully practised, demonstrate its effectiveness in improving relevance, acceptance, and sustainability.

Capacity strengthening is recognised as central to LLD, but participating local partners report that existing approaches often remain training-oriented and externally defined.  Meaningful capacity strengthening, from local partner perspectives, involves the promotion and enabling of increased autonomy, stronger governance systems, negotiation power, resource mobilisation capacity, and organisational resilience – not training delivery alone.

MEAL systems are largely oriented towards upward accountability to donors through reporting, compliance, and predefined indicators. Local partners measure programme delivery, outputs, participation, and financial accountability within frameworks designed by donors and INGOs while dimensions more closely associated with progress on LLD – such as local agency, ownership, trust, and mutual accountability – remain weakly captured.

Recommendations summary

The findings of this research are intended for donors and INGOs, specifically the Irish Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT Ireland) and the membership of Dóchas. While full recommendations are presented in the “Recommendations” tab, there are three main recommendations:

Develop an integrated approach to evaluating the shift to LLD, focusing on behavioural change by tracking a range of metrics along a progressive continuum

Prioritise the long-term transfer of control over resources and decision-making, rather than limiting focus to funding flows alone

Adopt an initial menu of metrics as a shared reference point to encourage an incremental move toward LLD

A sample menu is provided in the “Menu of Metrics” tab (it is also available in the PDF report, page 23).

Share this page: